Skip to content
CirqlPricing

Sample, not a real company

This is what a Cirql field report looks like after the interviews are in. Data below is from a fictional industrial manufacturer, with the same structure, aggregations, and visuals you'll get from your own campaign.

Q2 2026 · Operations assessment

Midwest Precision Manufacturing

A field report from 18 interviews across 3 sites and four rungs, floor to COO. Every number below is derived from the interviews. Quotes are verbatim; names appear only when the respondent opted in.

At a glance
8findings
surfaced across all interviews
218.4hrs / week
of quantified friction
6candidates
worth ~84 hrs/wk if implemented
18interviews
4 rungs, 3 sites
Rung coverage
10floor5supervisor2leader1executive
Attribution

7 of 18 opted in to attributed quotes. The rest are quoted by rung.

§ i

Time allocation

218.4 hrs/week of friction identified across 18 respondents.

Friction heatmap, role × shift (approx hrs/wk)

Estimated from role and shift distributions
morning
swing
office
night
Line Operator68h
29.3
18.2
13.1
7.3
Shift Supervisor42.5h
18.3
11.4
8.2
4.6
QA Technician31h
13.4
8.3
6
3.3
Scheduler28.3h
12.2
7.6
5.4
3.1
Maintenance Tech22h
9.5
5.9
4.2
2.4
Plant Manager18.5h
8
5
3.6
2

By site

  • Cleveland Plant139.8 hrs/wk, 11 ppl
  • Akron Plant62.5 hrs/wk, 5 ppl
  • HQ Office16.1 hrs/wk, 2 ppl

By department

  • Production102.4 hrs/wk, 9 ppl
  • Quality48 hrs/wk, 3 ppl
  • Scheduling28.3 hrs/wk, 2 ppl
  • Maintenance22 hrs/wk, 2 ppl
  • Leadership17.7 hrs/wk, 2 ppl
§ ii

System landscape

28 spreadsheet-citing findings, 19 paper-trail findings, 5 tool categories.

Overlaps (same job, multiple tools)

ERP
SAP×15Plex MES×7
Spreadsheet
Schedule.xlsx×12OEE tracker.xlsx×8Scrap log.xlsx×6PM schedule.xlsx×4

Orphans (frustration, no widespread owner)

  • PM schedule.xlsx Mentioned by 4 people with 3 friction findings — former maintenance lead owned it; no current owner.
  • Scrap log.xlsx Mentioned by 6 people with 2 friction findings — only one scheduler maintains it, no backup.

All tools by category

ERP
SAP×15Plex MES×7
Spreadsheet
Schedule.xlsx×12OEE tracker.xlsx×8Scrap log.xlsx×6PM schedule.xlsx×4
Paper
Clipboard travelers×9QA sign-off forms×14
Communication
Teams×10Text messaging×6
Docs
SharePoint×8
§ graph

The operations graph

Every person, tool, and finding from this assessment, and how they connect. Hover or search to walk the neighborhood. Orange diamonds are high-impact findings.

Operations graph, from this campaign's interviewsLive
Groups
§ iii

Friction log

Ranked by severity-adjusted impact: emotional drain weighs in, not just hours. Each finding grounded in a real interview quote.

i.

QA sign-off is a single-supervisor bottleneck

9.1sev-adj impact

“Every lot waits on Dan. If he's in a meeting, the line sits. I've waited 45 minutes for a sign-off on a lot that took 20 minutes to run.”

A floor operator (Production)
Frequency
per_shift
Hrs/week cost
32.5
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor, leader
moderatetools: QA sign-off forms, SAP
ii.

Every work order is re-keyed from SAP into Schedule.xlsx

8.8sev-adj impact

“The scheduler exports from SAP, cleans it in Excel, and re-imports. Nobody trusts SAP's native scheduling because the data goes stale overnight.”

Maya Patel, Production Scheduler
Frequency
daily
Hrs/week cost
17.3
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor
quick-wintools: SAP, Schedule.xlsx
iii.

Shift handoff happens in 8 different ways across lines

7.4sev-adj impact

“Day shift writes on the whiteboard, swing texts me, nights emails themselves. Nothing's written down the same way twice.”

A supervisor (Production)
Frequency
per_shift
Hrs/week cost
12.6
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor
quick-wintools: Teams, Text messaging, Clipboard travelers
iv.

Forklift waiting at Akron dock blocks inbound receiving

6.7sev-adj impact

“We've got two drivers and one dock, and on Tuesday mornings when the SAP schedule drops we're stacked up for an hour.”

A floor operator (Akron Plant)
Frequency
weekly
Hrs/week cost
6.8
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor
moderatetools: SAP
v.

Cleveland runs paper travelers; Akron moved to digital 2 years ago

6.5sev-adj impact

“We scan them at the end of the shift. Half the time the handwriting is bad and someone has to call the operator back.”

A QA technician (Cleveland Plant)
Frequency
per_shift
Hrs/week cost
10.1
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor, leader
initiativetools: Clipboard travelers, SAP
vi.

OEE tracker.xlsx is manually updated 3x per shift

6.2sev-adj impact

“I'd love to automate it but nobody owns that workbook — I just inherited it when Gary retired.”

A scheduler (Cleveland Plant)
Frequency
daily
Hrs/week cost
7.5
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor
quick-wintools: OEE tracker.xlsx, SAP
vii.

PM checklists are maintained by nobody

5.4sev-adj impact

“Frank used to keep it updated. He retired in November. Now when new techs ask, we just point at the binder.”

A maintenance tech (Cleveland Plant)
Frequency
weekly
Hrs/week cost
4.3
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
floor, supervisor
quick-wintools: PM schedule.xlsx
viii.

SAP / Plex MES data-sync delay means schedulers work off stale data

5.3sev-adj impact

“The batches that closed at 2am don't show up in SAP until morning. So our 7am schedule is already wrong.”

Maya Patel, Production Scheduler
Frequency
daily
Hrs/week cost
5.8
Severity
Not set
Respondents
1
Rungs
supervisor, leader
initiativetools: SAP, Plex MES
§ iv

Automation shortlist

Ranked by ROI: hours saved per week divided by effort-to-fix score. Split by who solves it: Cirql (or an in-house dev team) vs. your own ops leadership.

Cirql can build for you5 candidates
i.

Re-keying work orders SAP → Schedule.xlsx (schedulers)

“Exports, clean-up, re-import. Every single morning.” Maya Patel, Production Scheduler

SAPSchedule.xlsx
Cirql-buildable · $2,500 credit applies
17.3hrs saved / wk
Effort: quick-win
ROI 17.3
ii.

OEE tracker.xlsx manual entry 3x/shift

“I inherited the workbook; nobody trained me on a better way.” A scheduler (Cleveland Plant)

OEE tracker.xlsxSAP
Cirql-buildable · $2,500 credit applies
7.5hrs saved / wk
Effort: quick-win
ROI 7.5
iii.

PM checklist maintenance + onboarding handoff

“It's a Word doc on SharePoint from 2019. New techs never find it.” A maintenance tech (Cleveland Plant)

PM schedule.xlsxSharePoint
Cirql-buildable · $2,500 credit applies
4.3hrs saved / wk
Effort: quick-win
ROI 4.3
iv.

Standardized shift-handoff form (one template, three shifts)

“Day writes on the board, swing texts, nights emails themselves. No standard.” A supervisor (Production)

TeamsClipboard travelers
Cirql-buildable · $2,500 credit applies
12.6hrs saved / wk
Effort: moderate
ROI 4.2
v.

Cleveland paper traveler → digital (match Akron's rollout)

“Half the handwriting is bad and we call operators back.” A QA technician (Cleveland Plant)

Clipboard travelersSAP
Cirql-buildable · $2,500 credit applies
10.1hrs saved / wk
Effort: initiative
ROI 1.7
Your team handles1 candidate
i.

Cross-train a second QA lead to unblock sign-off

“Every lot waits on Dan.” A floor operator (Production)

QA sign-off forms
Process / ownership
32.5hrs saved / wk
Effort: initiative
ROI 5.4
projection

Fix the top 3 quick-wins and you reclaim 29.1 hrs/week.

Projection assumes linear time savings and ~50 working weeks/year. It does not include second-order effects (unblocked downstream work, fewer handoff errors, morale), which typically compound this number.

29.1hrs / week

reclaimed across quick-win candidates

1,455hrs / year

at steady state

2rungs affected

findings touch roles across these rungs

§ v

The ascent

Rung coverage: 10 floors, 5 supervisors, 2 leaders, 1 executive.

Validated by higher rung

  • QA sign-off is a single-supervisor bottleneck

    “Every lot waits on Dan.”

    Rungs: floor, supervisor, leader, impact 9.1
  • Every work order is re-keyed from SAP into Schedule.xlsx

    “Nobody trusts SAP's native scheduling.”

    Rungs: floor, supervisor, impact 8.8
  • Cleveland runs paper travelers; Akron moved to digital

    “Half the handwriting is bad.”

    Rungs: floor, supervisor, leader, impact 6.5

Reported by floor, not confirmed above

  • SAP / Plex MES data-sync delay

    “Our 7am schedule is already wrong.”

    Rungs: supervisor, leader, impact 5.3

Floor orphans (no supervisor interviewed yet)

  • Forklift waiting at Akron dock blocks inbound receiving

    “We're stacked up for an hour.”

    Rungs: floor, impact 6.7
  • PM checklists are maintained by nobody

    “Frank used to keep it updated. He retired in November.”

    Rungs: floor, impact 5.4

Top-down only (not yet grounded by floor)

  • Cost-of-goods-sold drift at Akron is an unexplained 3.2 pts

    “Something's moved but we can't pinpoint it.”

    Rungs: executive, impact 4.8

Your turn

Run one of these for your own plant.

Buy the code for $199 and run it yourself, or have us run it with you from $2,500, four runs over twelve months, each one showing what changed since the last.